Earnings Management And Board Characteristics: Evidence From French Listed Firms
Downloads
The purpose of this paper is to test the effect of the board characteristics including; its size, independence, the CEO duality and its activity on the earnings management in companies listed on the SBF 250.We use discretionary accruals (DA) as a proxy for the earnings management. To calculate DA, we use two models which are the modified Jones model (Dechow et al. 1995) and performance-matched discretionary accruals estimated from the modified Jones model (Kothari et al. 2005). Based on a sample of 70 French listed companies over the period of 4 years from 2008 to 2012, the study finds that the earnings management is negatively associated with the board size. This suggests that large boards are more effective in monitoring a CEO‘s action. The CEO duality is found to have a positive relationship with the earnings management suggesting that, by combining the role of the CEO and that of the chairman of the board helps increase the earnings management because the CEO may reduce the effectiveness of the board and create a conflict between the management and the board that may reduce the earnings management. Moreover, the board activity is found to have a positive relation with the earnings management suggesting that a board meeting more often helps to increase the earnings management. The present study finds no effect of the board independence on the earnings
management. This result is in contradiction with previous studies that have found a significant negative relationship between these two variables (Klein (2002), Xie et al. 2003), Peasnell et al.2005, Supawadee et al. 2013). Overall, from the result of this study, we conclude that the earnings management takes place in French listed companies.
Beasley, M (1996). An empirical analysis
of the relation between the board of
director Composition and financial
statement fraud, The Accounting Review,
Vol 71, N°4, pp.443-465.
Beneish, M (2001). Earnings management
»Managerial Finance, emeraldinsight.com
Bradbury and al (2004) “Board
Characteristics, Audit Committee
Characteristics and Abnormal Accruals”
ssrn.com/abstract=535764
Breton.G et Schatt.A (2005)
« Manipulation comptable ; les dirigeants
et les autres parties prenantes « la revue
financier » n°139, pp18-25
Casta (2009) « Théorie positive de la
comptabilité » de comptabilité, contrôle de
gestion et audit, - halshs.archivesouvertes.
fr
Chalayer.S (1995) « le lissage de résultat ;
élément explicatifs avancés dans la
littérature « comptabilité, contrôle, audit,
Tome 1, vol2, pp97-116
Charreaux. G (1997), « Le gouvernement
des entreprises : théories et faits »,
Economica, Paris ;
Cheng .Q et Werfield.T.D (2005) “Equity
incentives and earning management”
Accounting Review n°80, pp441-476
Chtourou, M. S, Bédard, J et Courteau, L
(2001), « Corporate governance and
earnings management », Working paper,
Laval University, pp. 1-41;
Chi-Keung, Man (2012) “Corporate
Governance and Earnings Management: A
Survey of Literature “Working Paper
Cornett, M. M, Marcus, A. J, Saunders, A
et Tehranien, H (2006), “Earnings
management, Corporate governance, and
true financial performance”, SSRN
Working Papers, pp. 1-28
Cormier .D .Magnan.M et Morard .B
(1998) » la gestion stratégique des
résultats ; le modèle Anglo saxon convient
il au contexte suisse ?comptabilité,
contrôle, Audit, Tome 4 vol 1 pp25-48
Davidson, R; Goodwin-Stewart, J et Kent,
P (2005), « Internal governance structures
and earnings management”, Accounting
and Finance, Vol 45, pp. 241-267;
Dechow, P; Sloan, R et Sweeney A, P
(1995), “Detecting earnings management”,
The Accounting Review, Vol 70, N° 2, pp.
-225;
Dechow, P et Skinner.D (2000) ”Earning
management , reconciling the views of
accountable academics, practitioners and
regulators “Accounting Horizons vol 14
n°2,pp235-250
Dechow .P, Sloan .D et Sweeney .A
(1996)”causes and consequences of
earning manipulations “contemporary
Accounting Research n°13pp1-36
Defond .M et Jiambalvo .L (1994)
“Factors related to auditors –client
disagreements over income increasing
accounting methods “contemporary
Accounting Research pp 145-161
Degeorge .F,Patel .J et Zeckhauser, R
(1999) “Earning management to exceed
Thresholds” the journal of Business
vol72,n°1 PP1-33
Donnelly, R et Lynch, C (2002), “The
ownership structure of UK firms and the
informativeness of accounting earnings”,
Accounting and Business Research, Vol
, N° 4, pp. 245-257;
Darroungh.S et Rangan.M (2005) « Do
insider manipulate earning when they selltheir Shares in an initial public offering
“journal of accounting Research, vol
pp1-33
Fama, E. F (1980), “Agency problems and
theory of the firm”, Journal of Political
Economy, Vol 88, N°2, Avril, pp. 288-
;
Fama, E et Jensen, M (1983), “Separation
of ownership and control”, Journal of law
and economics”, Vol 27, pp. 301-326;
Forker, J.J (1992), “Corporate governance
and disclosure quality”, Accounting and
Business Research, Vol 22, Iss 86, pp.111-
;
F Lakhal (2006) « Les mécanismes de
gouvernement d'entreprise et la publication
volontaire des résultats en France -
Comptabilité-Contrôle-Audit,
Godard, L et Schatt, A (2004), «
Caractéristiques et fonctionnement des
conseils d’administration français »,
Cahier du FARGO, N°1040201, Février,
pp. 1-27 ;
Healy. P ( 1985 ) evidence on the effect
of bonus schemaes on accounting
procedure and accruals decision »journal
of Accounting and Economics vol7 n°1-3
pp85-107
Healy .P et Wahlen.J (1999)”A revew of
earning manement literature and its
implications for standard setting “
accounting Horizon vol 13 n°4 pp 365-383
Hermalin, B. E., and M. S. Weisbach
(2000). Boards of directors as an
endogenously determined institution: A
survey of the economic literature. U. C.
Berkley Working Paper
Jeanjean, T (2002), « Gestion du résultat :
mesure et démesure », Working Paper,
Communication au 23ièm Congrès de
l’Association Française de Comptabilité,
pp. 1-22
Jenjean 1999 « la théorie positif en
comptabilité ; une revue de
critique, »Cahier 99 – 12 du CEREG,
Université Paris – Dauphine
Jeanjean 2000 ‘incitations et contrainte de
gestion de résultat » "» comptabilité,
control, audit tome 7 vol 1 pp 61 -76
Jensen et Meckling w (1976) Theory of the
firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs
and ownership structure - Journal of
financial economics, 1976 - Elsevier
Jones (1991) « Earning management
during import relief investigations
« journal of accounting Research vol 29 pp
-228
Karaa, A et Sellami. M (2003), «
Contribution à l’analyse de l’influence du
conseil d’administration et du comité
d’audit sur la gestion stratégique des
résultats : cas des sociétés de la SBF 120
», Working Paper, Conférence
Internationale de Finance, Mars, pp. 1-24 ;
Klein, A (2002), “Audit committee, board
of directors and earnings management”,
Journal of Accounting and Research, Vol
, Iss 3, June;
Labelle.R et Thibault.M (1998) “ gestion
du benefice à la crise environnementale ;
test de l’hypothèse de cout politique «
comptabilité, contrôle, audit vol 4 n°3
pp17-32
Liu .Q et LU Z .j (2007) »corporate
governance and earning management in
the chine listed companies. A tunneling
perspective” journal of corporate finance
n°13 pp881-906
Le Maux, J (2005), « La coalition du
contrôle : une spécificité du gouvernement
d’entreprise français », Working Paper,
XVIème Conférence internationale de
management stratégique, Pays de la Loire,
Angers 2005, pp. 1-27 ;39. M.Gulzar (2011) « Corporate Governance
Characteristics and Earnings Management:
Empirical Evidence from Chinese Listed
Firms » International Journal of
Accounting and Financial Reporting ISSN
-3082 2011, Vol. 1, No. 1
Mard .I 2005 “vers une information
comptable plus transparente ; l’apport de
recherché portant sur la gestion de resultat
comptable “ www .google.fr
Magnan, M., C. Nadeau, and D. Cormier
(1999). Earnings management during
antidumping investigations: Analysis and
implications. Canadian Journal of
Administrative Sciences 16:149-162.
Mard (2004) la gestion de resultat ;
influence de politique financier,
performance et de contrôle 25ÈME
CONGRES DE L'AFC, 2004 -
halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr
Maati, J (1999), “Le gouvernement de
l’entreprise », DeBoeck Université, Paris-
Bruxelles Matoussi, H et Mahfoudh, I
(2006), « Composition du conseil
d’administration et gestion opportuniste
des résultats », Working Paper, Congès de
l’Association Francophone de
Comptabilité, pp. 1-22 ;
Park, Y. W et Shin, H (2004), “Board
composition and earnings management in
Canada”, Journal of Corporate Finance,
Vol 10, pp. 431-457;
Peasnell, K; Pope, P et Young, S (1998),
“Outside directors, board effectiveness and
earnings management”, Working Paper,
Accounting Research Network, disponible
sur
http://ssrn.com/update/arn_finacctg.html;
Pfeffer, J (1972), “Size and composition of
corporate boards of directors: the
organization and its environment”,
Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol 17,
pp. 218-228;
Piot, C et Janin, R (2004), «Qualité de
l’audit, gouvernance et gestion du résultat
comptable en France », Working Paper,
ième colloque international gouvernance
et juricomptabilité : les enjeux, Juin,
Montréal Canada, pp. 1 ;
Prity Kumari (2014)” The Role of Board
Characteristics as a Control Mechanism of
Earnings Management: A Study of Select
Indian Service Sector Companies” The
IUP Journal of Corporate Governance,
Vol. XIII, No. 1, January 2014, pp. 58-69
Rapport Viénot (1999), « rapport du
comité sur le gouvernement d’entreprise,
AFEP - MEDEF, Juillet, 33 pages ;
Shleifer, A et Vishny, R. W (1997), “A
survey of corporate governance”, Journal
of Finance, Vol 52, pp. 737-783;
Stolowy H (2000) « la comptabilité
créative ‘ comptabilité, contrôle et audit
Supawadee Sukeecheep, Subba Reddy
Yarram and Omar Al Farooque (2013)”
Earnings Management and Board
Characteristics in Thai Listed Companies”
,The 2013 IBEA, International Conference
on Business, Economics, and Accounting
– 23 March 2013, Bangkok – Thailand
Vafeas, N (2000), “Board structure and the
informativeness of earnings”, Journal of
Accounting and Public Policy, Vol 19,
summer, pp. 139-160;
Watt and Zimmerman 1978 « Towards a
positive theory of the determination of
accounting standards" « The Accounting
Revue
Xie B, Davidson III, W. N et Dadalt, P. J
(2003), « Earnings management: the role of
the board and the audit committee », Journal
of Corporate Finance, Vol 9, pp. 295-316.
