Manipulative Design in The Digital Age: Trends and Impacts of Dark Patterns On Social Media Users
Downloads
This study examines dark patterns in social media apps using bibliometric analysis and qualitative review of 32 Scopus-indexed articles (2015-2024). This study aims to identify research trends, key themes, and gaps related to manipulative interface designs that influence user behavior. The results of this study show that publication activity has increased since 2020, although citation impact remains low. Common dark patterns found include privacy zuckering, confirm shaming, and infinite scrolling-tactics that exploit cognitive biases and affect user decisions, privacy, and mental well-being. Children and adolescents are particularly vulnerable due to their limited ability to detect manipulation. Thematic mapping reveals dominant themes such as decision-making, privacy, and behavioral health, while areas such as digital well-being and user consent remain under-explored. Tools such as Bibliometrix and Biblioshiny were used to visualize trends, collaborations and keyword networks. This research contributes to understanding how dark patterns shape digital behavior and highlights the need for ethical design practices and regulatory frameworks in online environments.
Bourdoucen, Amel, Leysan Nurgalieva, and Janne Lindqvist. 2023. “Privacy Is the Price: Player Views and Technical Evaluation of Data Practices in Online Games.” Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 7(CHI PLAY).
Butori, Raphaëlle and Caroline Lancelot Miltgen. 2023. A Construal Level Theory Approach to Privacy Protection: The Conjoint Impact of Benefits and Risks of Information Disclosure. Vol. 168.
Cho, Hyunsung, Daeun Choi, Donghwi Kim, Wan Ju Kang, Eun Kyoung Choe, and Sung-Ju Lee. 2021. “Reflect, Not Regret: Understanding Regretful Smartphone Use with App Feature-Level Analysis.” Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 5(CSCW2).
Cristóbal-Fransi, E., B. Ferrer-Rosell, and N. Daries- Ramon. 2017. “Segmentation of Seniors Based on Products Bought on the Internet: Impact on Tourism Industry.” Cuadernos de Turismo (40):175–656.
Cross, Shane P. and Mario Alvarez-Jimenez. 2024. “The Digital Cumulative Complexity Model: A Framework for Improving Engagement in Digital Mental Health Interventions.” Frontiers in Psychiatry 15.
Davis, Teaniese, Ralph Joseph DiClemente, and Michael Prietula. 2020. “Using ADAPT-ITT to Modify a Telephone-Based HIV Prevention Intervention for SMS Delivery: Formative Study.” JMIR Formative Research 4(10).
Desimpelaere, Laurien, Liselot Hudders, and Dieneke de Sompel. 2021. “Children’s Perceptions of Fairness in a Data Disclosure Context: The Effect of a Reward on the Relationship between Privacy Literacy and Disclosure Behavior.” Telematics and Informatics 61.
Dogruel, Leyla, Sven Joeckel, and Jakob Henke. 2023. “Disclosing Personal Information in MHealth Apps. Testing the Role of Privacy Attitudes, App Habits, and Social Norm Cues.” Social Science Computer Review 41(5):1791 – 1810.
Epstein, Robert and Vanessa R. Zankich. 2022. “The Surprising Power of a Click Requirement: How Click Requirements and Warnings Affect Users’ Willingness to Disclose Personal Information.” PLoS ONE 17(2 February 2022):1–21.
Gotsch, Mauro Luis and Marcus Schögel. 2023. Addressing the Privacy Paradox on the Organizational Level: Review and Future Directions. Vol. 73. Springer International Publishing.
Guath, Mona, Britt Stikvoort, and Peter Juslin. 2022. “Nudging for Eco-Friendly Online Shopping – Attraction Effect Curbs Price Sensitivity.” Journal of Environmental Psychology 81(May):101821.
Hightow-Weidman, Lisa B., Keith J. Horvath, Hyman Scott, Jonathan Hill-Rorie, and Jose A. Bauermeister. 2021. “Engaging Youth in MHealth: What Works and How Can, We Be Sure?” MHealth 7.
Ioannou, Athina, Iis Tussyadiah, and Alaa Marshan. 2021. “Dispositional Mindfulness as an Antecedent of Privacy Concerns: A Protection Motivation Theory Perspective.” Psychology and Marketing 38(10):1766 – 1778.
Kezer, Murat, Tobias Dienlin, and Lemi Baruh. 2022. “Getting the Privacy Calculus Right: Analyzing the Relations Between Privacy Concerns, Expected Benefits, and Self-Disclosure Using Response Surface Analysis.” Cyberpsychology 16(4).
Kim, Byoungsoo and Daekil Kim. 2020. “Understanding the Key Antecedents of Users’ Disclosing Behaviors on Social Networking Sites: The Privacy Paradox.” Sustainability (Switzerland) 12(12).
Klütsch, Jennifer, Christian Böffel, Lukas Abraham, Janina Mooser, Dominik Thüs, Parwana Tawanger, Sophia von Salm-Hoogstraeten, and Sabine J. Schlittmeier. 2024. “How Users Make Online Privacy Decisions in Work and Personal Contexts of Use.” Scientific Reports 14(1).
Kozyreva, Anastasia, Stephan Lewandowsky, and Ralph Hertwig. 2020. “Citizens Versus the Internet: Confronting Digital Challenges with Cognitive Tools.” Psychological Science in the Public Interest 21(3):103 – 156.
Krpan, Dario and Milan Urbaník. 2024. “From Libertarian Paternalism to Liberalism: Behavioural Science and Policy in an Age of New Technology.” Behavioural Public Policy 8(2):300 – 326.
Lenz, Julia, Zdravko Bozakov, Steffen Wendzel, and Simon Vrhovec. 2023. “Why People Replace Their Aging Smart Devices: A Push–Pull–Mooring Perspective.” Computers and Security 130:103258.
Li, Yuqin and Hanying Guo. 2022. “Sustainable Development of Shared Mobility in China in Relation to the Privacy Paradox of Users.” Journal of Advanced Transportation 2022.
Medina, Lana. 2024. “‘Fridays Are Racist’: Evaluating Social Media Engagement From a Virtue Ethics Framework.” International Journal of Technoethics 15(1).
Mills, Stuart. 2022. “Finding the ‘Nudge’ in Hypernudge.” Technology in Society 71.
Mills, Stuart and Henrik Skaug Sætra. 2024. “The Autonomous Choice Architect.” AI and Society 39(2):583 – 595.
Morita, Junya, Thanakit Pitakchokchai, Giri Basanta Raj, Yusuke Yamamoto, Hiroyasu Yuhashi, and Teppei Koguchi. 2022. “Regulating Ruminative Web Browsing Based on the Counterbalance Modeling Approach.” Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence 5.
Parker, Christopher J. and Hsin Yun Kuo. 2022. “What Drives Generation-y Women to Buy Fashion Items Online?” Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice 30(3):279–94.
Pinder, Charlie, Jo Vermeulen, Benjamin R. Cowan, and Russell Beale. 2018. “Digital Behaviour Change Interventions to Break and Form Habits.” ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 25(3).
M. J. Cobo, A. G. López-Herrera, E. Herrera-Viedma, and F. Herrera. 2011. “Science mapping software tools: Review, analysis, and cooperative study among tools,” J. Am. Soc. Inf. Sci. Technol., vol. 62, no. 7, pp. 1382– 1402.
Raja Mohd Ali, R. H., A. Ahmi, and S. Sudin. 2020. “Examining the Trend of the Research on the Internet of Things (IoT): A Bibliometric Analysis of the Journal Articles as Indexed in the Scopus Database.” Journal of Physics: Conference Series 1529(2).
Renaud, Karen, Cigdem Sengul, Kovila Coopamootoo, Bryan Clift, Jacqui Taylor, Mark Springett, and Ben Morrison. 2024. “‘We’re Not That Gullible!’ Revealing Dark Pattern Mental Models of 11-12-Year-Old Scottish Children.” ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 31(3).
Rixen, Jan Ole, Luca-Maxim Meinhardt, Michael Glöckler, Marius-Lukas Ziegenbein, Anna Schlothauer, Mark Colley, Enrico Rukzio, and Jan Gugenheimer. 2023. “The Loop and Reasons to Break It: Investigating Infinite Scrolling Behaviour in Social Media Applications and Reasons to Stop.” Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 7(MHCI).
Roffarello, Alberto Monge and Luigi De Russis. 2023. “Achieving Digital Wellbeing Through Digital Self- Control Tools: A Systematic Review and Meta- Analysis.” ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 30(4).
Rossi, Arianna, Rachele Carli, Marietjie W. Botes, Angelica Fernandez, Anastasia Sergeeva, and Lorena Sánchez Chamorro. 2024. “Who Is Vulnerable to Deceptive Design Patterns? A Transdisciplinary Perspective on the Multi-Dimensional Nature of Digital Vulnerability.” Computer Law and Security Review 55(October).
Saura, Jose Ramon, Vatroslav Škare, and Durdana Ozretic Dosen. 2024. “Is AI-Based Digital Marketing Ethical? Assessing a New Data Privacy Paradox.” Journal of Innovation and Knowledge 9(4).
Yardley, Lucy, Bonnie J. Spring, Heleen Riper, Leanne
G. Morrison, David H. Crane, Kristina Curtis, Gina C. Merchant, Felix Naughton, and Ann Blandford. 2016. “Understanding and Promoting Effective Engagement with Digital Behavior Change Interventions.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine 51(5):833 – 842.
